Anthony's of Guilford (2024)

Phone number

(203)533-42...— show

Address

Are you the owner?

• Get access
• Get a widget
• Report an error

• Joshua L.

  January 16, 2023, 4:49 am

  The Den atAnthony’s isnicely decorated and food was good. Good selection ofbeers. Staff was attentive. Prices were inflated. Wewere overcharged for several items. Decent experience.

  00

  Reply

• Canon b.

  November 11, 2022, 3:52 am

  Great food and service

  00

  Reply

• Peter N.

  April 23, 2022, 12:36 am

  Anthony's should close upshop. Used tobe great. Ordered aspinach and mozz stuffed bread and itwas tasteless. Noseasoning.

  00

  Reply

• Lewis S.

  February 15, 2022, 11:39 pm

  Awesome pizza every time

  00

  Reply

• Jeffrey S.

  October 13, 2021, 5:25 pm

  Best Pizza around, better than anything inNew Haven, Broccoli Rabe and Sausage, excellent, Old School!!!

  00

  Reply

• Bonnie

  June 15, 2021, 10:24 pm

  Bad customer service! Ihad anextremely frustrating experience last week with Anthony's takeout. At3:30pm, Iplaced (and paid for) anonline order of3stuffed breads totake toan event that started at6pm. Ishowed upat the time Idesignated onthe order form (5:30) and was told (very rudely, Imight add) that they cancelled the order at5pm because they don't dosame day stuffed bread orders. Asif I'm supposed toknow that--Iwas, afterall, able toorder andpay. They took noresponsibility--blaming the company that facilitates their online order process. Infact, the woman behind the cash register and the chef argued withme, asif itwas myfault. She even said their regular customers knew. Well, Iwas afirst time customer and that will bemy last time there. Asa small business owner, Iknow and appreciate the value oftaking care ofcustomers. They did nothing. Thank goodness Carpanzano's down the road had acase full ofstuffed breads. Ofcourse Iwas late tomy event because Ihad tomake another stop and take the time toheat upthe breads…Honestly, ifthey had treated mebetter, Iwould not bewriting this review, but their attitude towards meas acustomer was inexcusable.… – show

  00

  Reply

• Meagen L.

  April 24, 2021, 1:34 pm

  Friendly service

  00

  Reply

• Jamiey K.

  March 27, 2021, 4:57 am

  Are they hosting sunday brunch ever again. Itis hands down the best brunch inct. Imissit. Imiss the great selection, and the owners.always sonice. Please bring bsck Sunday Brunch. Idpay more.

  00

  Reply

• Ben G.

  February 13, 2021, 8:01 pm

  Great service fantastic food

  00

  Reply

• Andy T.

  December 31, 2020, 5:30 pm

  Excellent food! Their stuffed breads are the best you canbuy!! Especially their stromboli bread with peppers, onion, pepperoni!!! And their special order steak & cheese bread!!! Yummm! Owner are great accommodating folk!!

  00

  Reply

• Sue A.

  December 31, 2020, 5:43 am

  They make the best eggplant Parmesan. Ifrequently buy alarge tray and portion itout into smaller portions and freeze tohave iton hand athome. It’s afamily favorite.

  00

  Reply

• Camille B.

  November 18, 2020, 8:57 pm

  Boy dothese people know how tocook. Westopped here for the first time ever sowe tried afew different things onthe menu. Wealways like toorder apizza when trying anew Italian restaurant and itwas excellent. Words can't describe the delicious calzone wehad. The calzone weordered had sausage init. The crust ofthe calzone was thin and crispy and the filling was just the right amount ofricotta and mozzarella, perfectly balanced and sausage inevery bite. Their sausage ishomemade and out ofthis world. Ialso order the shrimp florentine. The shrimp were delicately fried with Ithink anegg batter coating that was light and very tasty and the sauce and spinach was perfect. Good size portion and even better the nextday. Last but not least, the pepperoni bread. Well, I've had many different stuffed breads from numerous restaurants but this one tops themall. Again, perfect balance ofmeat and cheese, crispy thin crust and delicious ingredients. Ifyou haven't stopped here tograb dinner for your family then you are missing out onexcellent quality food. Mytastebuds don't lie sogive Anthony's ofGuilford atry.… – show

  00

  Reply

• John F.

  October 6, 2020, 9:01 pm

  When Iam in-town tovisit family (grew upin Guilford), wealways order pizza from Anthony's atleast once. Our family believes that Anthony's ison par with other “famous” CTpizzarias. Their stuffed breads are also awesome. Love that they have cold Foxon Park soda. Typically there are only 2or 3people working (Covid!). Soit isbest toorder early.

  00

  Reply

• David C.

  September 21, 2020, 9:06 pm

  Very large seating area and great food

  00

  Reply

• Mick C.

  September 5, 2020, 1:38 am

  We are blessed with plenty ofsolid pizza options around here. Anthony's isclearly one ofthem, and isconsistent and the staff are always friendly and efficient. Itfeels like aplace that comes from family pride. And unlike the place down the road (that's also very good pizza), you don't have towait anhour and ahalf.

  00

  Reply

• peter l.

  May 9, 2020, 8:04 am

  Finally aLarge pizza that’s actually Large. Try their everything PIE it’s packed with stuff.

  00

  Reply

• Hank L.

  April 29, 2020, 2:16 am

  Great Italian!

  00

  Reply

• Elizabeth L.

  April 13, 2020, 12:42 am

  Thank you Anthony's for the wonderful Easter dinner wehad today. Everything was fresh and delicious and weare soappreciative ofyour efforts tomake Easter Day during this horrible time much brighter!

  00

  Reply

• Alexandria A.

  February 22, 2020, 4:37 pm

  last time myfamily and iwent here was over 10yearsago. westopped going asthey were constantly over salting the food, sowe decided togive them another try asit’s been awhile since our last visit. food was fine, there was nothing wrong withit, but itdefinitely wasn’t good enough towait anhourfor. service was painfully slow, but they definitely gave enough food. itjust shouldn’t take anhour toget usour food when all weordered was simple pasta dishes and aplain mozz pizza.

  00

  Reply

• Al M.

  February 21, 2020, 7:25 pm

  Pizza isfantastic

  00

  Reply

Average rating- 4.2based on69 reviews and123 ratings